Rated 4.5 out of 5Â by 257
Rated 5 out of 5Â by EnviableGreen Greatest. Eyeliner. EVER!
For the past year, I have been on agonizing search for the 'perfect eyeliner' for my waterline/inner rim. I have the most apallingly sensitive eyes. They are very dry and I put drops in several times a day.
I tried every makeup brand, literally, and bought dozens of different eyeliners. Waterproof, kohl, made specifically for the waterline, etc. Everyone failed me. They either made my eyes burn, or would bleed excessively to the outer corners of my eyes, barely even appear on my rims, or needed re-application at least every hour.
I had officially given up and accepted that there is no such thing as "the perfect eyeliner." I came across this eyeliner and thought it wouldn't hurt to try it. I was already planning a trip to return it because I believed it would be no different than everything else I tried.
Well, it was a stunner! It glides on so smoothly, doesn't irritate my eyes, doesn't bleed excessively, and stays on my lids for hours! It slightly runs after a few hours to my outer corners, but it's very light and barely noticeable. The color is so strong and I'm in love with the eyeliner! Thank you so much!
September 24, 2012
Rated 4 out of 5Â by NHReviewer Solved key issues with most eyeliners
Other than quite easy to draw, the best part of this eye liner is that it does NOT transfer smudge to my lower eye lids like most other liners I have used would do; AND, it is easy to remove at night time (use a damp Q-tip) when I wash my face, unlike other liners I used I had to spent significant amount of time to remove otherwise I would go to bed like a raccoon. No smudges and easiness to remove are two key things I need in an eye liner for everyday use and this is it.
But I wouldn't say this product is perfect yet. For example, you can't really draw a thin line. Also, the caps at the two ends should be made equal length -- when I had both caps off and need to put them back on after finishing the job, I twice in a week accidently put the shorter clear plastic cap for smudge tip on the crayon end of the pencil, ruining the tip of the crayon.
May 29, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5Â by VintageBelle Has this product changed?
I have used the Smoke pencil for years and loved it, but the last time I bought it, it seemed as if the formula has changed. The color doesn't lay down well any more, as though it is more waxy. Not sure if I will continue to use, or if I will shop for an alternative. Does anyone know if the formulation has changed in the past several months? Or did I get a bad pencil?
September 24, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5Â by cfmcl So~so
This eye lining pencil isn't the greatest, just so~so, especially for the price. It's true about what I read from other reviewers, the wobble factor. The mushroom color is nice though.
August 26, 2015